A major shift has emerged in Maine's high-stakes U.S. Senate race just ahead of Election Day. The final New York Times/Portland Press Herald/Siena College poll released Sunday shows Democratic nominee Troy Jackson leading five-term Republican incumbent Sen. Susan Collins by six percentage points. The survey of 714 likely Maine voters, conducted over the prior week, puts Jackson at 51% and Collins at 45%, with a margin of error of 4.3%.
This outcome represents a nine-point swing from the survey's September iteration, which had Collins ahead by three points. In a contest that could determine party control of the Senate, the latest figures suggest notable movement within the electorate. The rapid realignment is particularly striking in a state where Collins has traditionally relied on cross-party appeal and moderate framing to secure victories.
Shifts Among Independent and Crossover Voters
Cross-tabulations from the poll highlight key changes in voter alignments since late summer. In September, Collins captured 8% of Democratic respondents compared to Jackson’s 3% share of Republicans. The new survey indicates that Collins' crossover advantage has eroded, with Jackson gaining equivalent or superior ground among opposing party voters.
Among unenrolled voters—a critical constituency in Maine—Jackson now holds a 52% to 41% edge. That contrast marks a departure from September, when the two candidates were deadlocked among independents at 47% apiece. Meanwhile, voter sentiment regarding personal favorability has turned cooler toward the incumbent. Collins' favorability rating fell to 48%, with 49% expressing an unfavorable view. By contrast, Jackson sits at 45% favorable and 48% unfavorable, gaining ground despite heavy negative advertising campaigns from opposing outside political groups.
Economic concerns remain top-of-mind for respondents. Voters surveyed indicated greater trust in Jackson regarding the cost of living, while Collins held a single-point advantage on immigration matters. The broader economic picture has been further complicated by energy costs tied to the ongoing war involving Iran, an issue that hits close to home in the nation's most heating-oil-dependent state. Jackson has criticized Collins' initial deference to the presidential administration regarding the war's rollout, while Collins has emphasized her votes to halt hostilities and her work to secure regional fuel supplies.
Heated Debates and Heavy Spending
The campaign has featured several sharp personal exchanges and an influx of campaign dollars. Spending has reached historic levels for the state, with candidate committees raising roughly $50 million combined and outside organizations dropping nearly $150 million into the race.
Policy disputes over regional trade and tariffs have produced visible friction. In an October debate over trade relations with Canada, Jackson pushed back on Collins' record by asserting that Mainers "can't eat road salt," referencing a tariff exemption secured by the senator. In another debate exchange, after a crowd member interrupted proceedings to protest data center developments, Collins remarked that the speaker was "obviously one of Troy's supporters," prompting Jackson to respond directly with "Oh, shut up"—a moment that quickly made its way into political advertisement rotations.
Despite the polling shift, observers and constituents alike remain wary of predicting an absolute outcome. Many recall previous election cycles where polling undercounted the veteran senator's ultimate support.
"Never count out susan collins unfortunately. I've seen her come back from bad polls. She's like trump in that regard."
Others point out structural differences between this election and prior cycles, noting that Jackson's support has topped the 50% threshold in this survey, unlike previous challengers who remained trapped in the mid-40s during polling windows.
"I get it but look back at 2020. Both Collins and Gideon were consistently in the 40s and Collins had a positive net approval.
Neither of those are true - Jackson is consistently over 50% and Collins is net negative."
Ranked-Choice Rules May Delay Final Results
With just 4% of voters undecided or declining to state a preference in the Siena poll, the vast majority of the electorate appears settled. However, voters may not learn the official winner on election night.
Under Maine's ranked-choice voting law, if neither candidate earns an absolute majority of first-preference votes on the initial count, election officials will initiate a ranked-choice tabulation involving write-in and minor candidates. Whether the six-point margin holds or narrows into another post-election count, the race stands as one of the most closely watched contests in the country.